Ron wrote:
So ... social engineering, in a way that stake's a
caller's reputation.
The engineer is an ancient, archetypal figure. The engineer is the one who
makes things "work."
I am comfortable with that title.
Ron also wrote:
Fair enough. I can see how that can be valuable if
that's one's goal.
The way I see it, all callers are deeply involved in social engineering.
Some of them recognize it, take responsibility for it, and work to become
better at it. Others don't. That makes a difference. Making the dancing
"work" seems, to me, to be at the heart of what I do as a caller. If a
dance falls apart it will not be serving the goal of anyone. That's part
of the beauty of contra dance. Integrating the first-timers is possibly
the most effective strategy for making sure the dances do not fall apart.
Everyone has a stake in that goal.
Ron then wrote:
It's better than shadow dances where you have more
time with your shadow
than your partner - that's a personal gripe of mine as a dancer.
Follow-up question: Should a caller announce it as, essentially, a mixer
with a trail-buddy, and/or are there distinct pros / cons for / against
doing so?
Considering that the dancers have no opportunity to choose their shadow it
does come across as a bit "heavy-handed" to assign you a more significant
"other" than your selected partner. I don't consider it to be as bad as,
say, calling a mixer without announcing it in advance. I'm not sure it
would be worth the effort to explain what you are talking about in an
announcement about a "shadow" dance with a "special" shadow. Probably
best
to call such dances only rarely.
My philosophy is to give the dancers as much information as I can and trust
in them to make social decisions. I never try to "trick" the dancers into
doing anything. I think those kind of "gambits" and "ploys" are
corrosive
to the caller's relationship with the dancers. I let the dancers take the
lead in whatever social engineering we need to make the evening work. If I
see something that will help the dancers to make the evening "work" better
I will assume the support of the dancers and try to give them the
information they need to work towards that shared goal.
- Greg McKenzie
Santa Cruz, CA