Hmm...lots of comments about teaching. I must say that I don't agree
with all of them :-)
First, about implied comments in a workshop. While I agree that
nonverbal speech is important, we shouldn't promote it over the
content of what is said. If we really go down that path, we might as
well consider what clothes you wear, whether you speak with an accent,
and what side you part your hair (anybody else remember some people
mentioning that was why Al Gore lost the election in 2000?). Should
your nonverbal speech overpower the things you say -- it's just as
likely it's because of the things you're saying as it is your
nonverbal impressions.
Furthermore, if a dance is setting aside time for an introductory
workshop and organizers advertise it in promotional material, then
having new dancers go through figures is absolutely positively not a
"waste of time." Honestly, as a dancer -- if I'm going to bother to
cut my dinner short so I get to the dance early, I'm not expecting to
sit around and listen to a pep talk of how wonderful the dance is
going to be. I want to know what I'll be doing and how I'll be doing
it. If I wanted to learn on the fly, I would have showed up at the
start time at the dance. There is an implicit understanding that if
people show up early they want some value added...someone to show them
the ropes in a low-pressure situation. While we understand all contra
dancing to be low pressure, first-time dancers (especially those who
have never danced anything but the Macarena) are petrified...as
testified by many of my friends and colleagues I've tried to drag to
dances. We owe them a physical heads up on what to expect just as much
as we ought to build up their confidence.
Second, I'm surprised at all the suggestions about weight, buzzstep,
and eye contact. Personally, when I do introductory workshops, I want
to equip new dancers with the tools that will make them more likely to
succeed. I don't think giving weight and eye contact are necessarily a
part of that. And having them go through the motions of "buzzstep" can
be an instant turnoff for many people who feel as though they "can't
dance." As experienced dancers, those are the things WE value in a
great dance or great dance partner...the smoothness, the connection --
it's exciting TO US. But I think by and large, beginner dancers want
to just be at the right place at the right time. We can all remember
countless movie scenes, where the incompetent dancer leads his partner
into every nearby couple, who proceed to glare disapprovingly. That's
every non-dancer's nightmare. So my vote is to get them to face the
right direction during a swing, walk with their feet facing the right
direction, and where to end up when it's over. All the bells and
whistles of contra can come later.
That's not to say I wouldn't mention the concepts of weight, buzzstep,
or eye contact, but they are not central to a beginner's learning and
doesn't make them more or less able to do a dance. Alert them to the
existence of such things, but then leave it to them to pick it up
instinctively throughout the night. They'll be dancing with dozens of
partners who can impart the suggestions for more eye contact, weight,
or other enhancements to the dance. It behooves other dancers to coax
them along with those details, but from the get-go, I think those
topics are about as useful as telling them that it's customary in
circles for the gent's hand to be on the bottom and the lady's on top
--- they'll figure it out!
For my part, I try to use as many "location" type verbal cues
especially early on in my calling: up/down/across. Get newbies cued in
to how to find where they are and where the calls suggest they go. I
try to remind them about how to locate themselves, where to stand,
gents left/ladies right -- basically giving them the tools so that
even if they're lost in the *figure* of the dance, they're not lost on
where they are on the floor. The "contra grid" is so etched in our
minds, I think it's often hard to realize there was a time we didn't
understand it :-D
Anyway, enough of my diatribe...just had to comment on this thread!
-Sargon
Show replies by date