I called the variation tonight with the circular hey.  And yes, it flows wonderfully that
way.  I have called the original before and of course it's a great dance, but the
variation is also a lovely dance. Lots of flow and swirls.  Fun to watch.
And I can't validate it was Carol with the variation, I just know I danced it twice
and recorded it that way and associated it with Carol.
That's great info Alan!
Laur
 
 ________________________________
 From: Alan Winston <winston(a)slac.stanford.edu>
To: callers(a)sharedweight.net 
Sent: Saturday, September 28, 2013 6:39 PM
Subject: Re: [Callers] rocks and dirt by Erik Weberg
 
Distinctive figure totally stolen from an English dance called 
"Fenterlarick", incidentally.  (As Erik would be the first to 
acknowledge; I just like seeing old friends in these contexts, like the 
poussette -> hey in "Joyride".)
As to the changes: maybe Carol had seen too many people go right , left, 
right , left (Oops, left-hand balance, which of course you can do but if 
you're not expecting it is awkward); maybe she thought 
swing-chain-allemande might be a little too dizzy-making (even though it 
nicely changes direction), maybe  she thought the dance needed a moment 
of poise (get yourself sorted out in long lines; don't reflexively chain 
back when you should be allemanding.)
So it could be orientation or it could be flow.  I guess I'd be hesitant 
to make a change that removes the neighbor swing.
-- Alan
On 9/28/2013 2:27 PM, Laur wrote:
  The first couple times I danced this I copied it
down, so I know that this was a version of the original.  I believe it was Carol Ormand
who called the dance both times, but I'm not certain.
 Can anyone share their opinion on why the caller would have chosen to make the change in
the dance?  orientation or flow?
 Rocks & Dirt  Erik Weberg  Type: Contra  Formation: Duple-Improper Level: Int
 A1 -----------
 Neighbor allemande Left 1-1/2 (8)
 Women's Chain (8)
 A2 -----------
 Long lines, forward and back (8)
 Ladies by the Right, Gents go round
 Women allemande Right 1-1/2 (8) while gents Orbit CCW to the other side
 B1 -----------
 Partner balance and swing (16)
 B2 -----------
 Circle Left 3/4 (6)
 Square thru to the new ( OR 3 place circular hey without hands )
     Ngh Pull by Right - P Left - Ngh Right  on to the next with your left
 OR Pass 1st Ngh by the Right, Partner Left, Neighbor Right   face the  next for an alm
Left
 original dance on Erick's site - A1 N B/S  A2 Ladies Chain; Orbit {Ladies Al'd R
1-1/2 while men orbit ccw 1/2 way around}
  
 ~
 When I dance, I cannot judge, I cannot hate, I cannot separate myself from life. I can
only be joyful and whole, that is why I dance.  ~Hans Bos~
 ~
 _______________________________________________
 Callers mailing list
 Callers(a)sharedweight.net
 
http://www.sharedweight.net/mailman/listinfo/callers 
_______________________________________________
Callers mailing list
Callers(a)sharedweight.net
http://www.sharedweight.net/mailman/listinfo/callers