Re: [Callers] Opposite StarThru and functional difference in LD v Slide

On Mar 21, 2019, at 12:02 PM, John Sweeney via Callers <callers(a)lists.sharedweight.net> wrote: While I hold Larry Jennings in extremely high regard, this is one of the few topics on which I'd venture to differ with him. I think there are many situations where the more specific terms will be not only more concise, but also more effective than "twirl to swap" plus the necessary additional words. The most case is in extemporaneously-called square dance sequences, but I it also applies for no-walk-through contra medleys and even for an ordinary contra dance (with walk-through) if the dance sequence includes more than one kind of "twirl to swap" action. Of course the more specific terms will only be effective if dancers are familiar with them, which they won't be if their local callers avoid those terms as much as possible. Since John has mentioned _Give-and-Take_, there's something I else I should mention. In the book, there's a table listing various ways for dancers to swap places (Box the Gnat, California Twirl, etc.) with info about what hands to use and which way people turn. *DO NOT* trust this table!! It is riddled with errors. Among other things, I suspect that at some point between different drafts of the book, the column headings for the men's actions and the women's actions got swapped but the individual entries didn't all get updated accordingly. And I must presume that this happened at a stage when Larry no longer the energy to check up on things as thoroughly as he would have in healthier days. Besides some apparent reversals of men's and women's roles there are some other things that strike me as incorrect, or at least ambiguous. Unfortunately, I didn't look at the table carefully enough to notice these points and report them or seek clarification while Larry was still living. --Jim