On Wed, Apr 10, 2013 at 1:33 PM, Dave Casserly
<david.j.casserly(a)gmail.com> wrote:
If men in the UK are so uncomfortable touching another
man that they don't
want to swing (which is, in its essence, simply placing one hand on the
man's back and one on a hand, not exactly an intimate embrace), that is
unacceptably homophobic.
The social implications matter much more than the actions. Consider
the difference between a gypsy and a swing. In a swing you hold onto
each other, look at each others eyes, and move in a circle. In a
gypsy you do mostly the same thing without touching. Yet the gypsy is
more charged, more flirty, and a bit more intimate. [1] Or consider
going the other way, from a swing to an aleman, where you still have
the touching and the eye contact, but the intimacy is much more
reduced than you might expect from just the change in hand positions.
At a contra dance in DC or Boston, two men dancing together indicates
little about their sexual orientations. Sure, men who often dance
with men are on average more likely to be attracted to men, but there
are enough straight men who dance with other men that it's not a very
reliable signal. If you go to a place where men don't usually dance
together and everyone thinks of that as something that only gay men
do, then men choosing to dance with each other sends a different
signal. I think a lot of the resistance men give to swinging or
gypsying with each other is that they don't want the caller to make
them signal something they're not.
Mainstream dance communities where men are ok dancing with each other
differ from those where they're not in two main ways: being gay is
acceptable and not very important, and men dance together for reasons
other than sexual orientation often enough that it doesn't say much
about them. These are related: the worse it is for me socially if
people start thinking I'm gay, the less willing I will be to dance
with my male friends.
Jeff
[1] Some of this is that the focus of a gypsy is the eye contact in a
way that the eye contact is only secondary in a swing. But there's a
different interpretation of gypsies.