As a dancer, I much prefer mixers to no-partner-swing dances. I haven't
called either much, but in my experience as a dancer in various communities
I have often seen mixers favorably received. In fact, I've been to a number
of smaller dance weekends where mixers were welcomed as a way to see who was
there, "scout" for partners, add variety to the evening, etc. In those
situations, the idea of "forcing" beginners to integrate wasn't relevant.
I
think mixers at regularly scheduled dances can serve the same purpose.
Maybe in communities with a lot of booking ahead for partners mixers might
cause more of a stir.
Another point:
I (like many people) only dance with any particular partner once during the
course of a normal length dance evening. If a no-partner-swing dance means
I don't get to swing with a good/favorite partner, I feel gypped. However,
I don't count a mixer as a dance with any particular partner so I get the
benefit of lots of interaction with many dancers without feeling like I'm
ignoring or missing out on dancing with my partner.
That being said, I wouldn't totally discount dances without a partner swing.
If the dance were unique or particularly interesting in some way I would
consider it. But if there were a similar dance with a partner swing I would
chose that one instead.
-Bronwyn