I, too, have struggled with this issue, going from men/women terminology to gents/ladies
while explaining that they are roles, not genders. I never took to larks/robins due to
the aforementioned “I hear ‘lark’ and it triggers ‘lady’ in my mind.” And that still
happens. Decades of dancing with gents/ladies terminology can do that.
I’ve always felt that a huge role of the caller was to do their best to promote fun and
happiness on the dance floor. That seems impossible to do when so many people get upset
about terminology. When the gypsy kerfuffle started, people in my dance community were
divided - with very strong opinions - about how to that move should be called. It felt
like no matter how I called it, I’d get angry looks from some of the dancers (along with
the occasional jeers). So… for years, I stopped calling the move. I’d change it to an
allemande, a do-si-do, or just not call a dance with that move in it. When it finally
seemed settled in my community that right shoulder round was the accepted terminology, I
called it again using what seemed to be the now agreed upon phrase. And of course, the
first time I called it, a person on the floor looked up at the stage and yelled, “You mean
gypsy?”
And then came non-gendered terminology. Trying to navigate that without upsetting a good
amount of dancers became increasingly difficult. The pandemic put that on hold for a few
years for me… and I made the decision that I would stay behind the piano and stop calling.
I saw no way to call that wasn’t going to upset a good number of dancers, and as a caller,
that was something I did not want to do.
But… as dancing resumed, there seemed to be a shortage of callers here and I ended up
being asked to call the first dance since the beginning of the pandemic. I was not
thrilled about calling ladies/gents, nor was I prepared to call larks/ravens. So I tackled
positional calling, and there were no complaints. None. Just compliments. I’ve called
since then and have been experimenting with ECD terminology of first corners / second
corners, and that seemed to work quite nicely - and it has the added benefit of helping
bridge the gap between dancers who only dance in one of those communities. Hopefully, it
will catch on with other local callers here, as that’s where I’m headed.
--
Jeffrey Spero
Culver City, CA