James,
Thanks for your studied reply to my post.
Jim wrote:
First, I see no point in urging dancers to brisk
circling in cases
where the action following "circle left 3/4; pass through" gives the
dancers adequate opportunity to make up time...
I agree with the suggestion of urging dancers to circle briskly. It's a
short, quick comment that can help. My concern was in structuring my calls
so that they match the timing of the dance precisely. My goal is to teach
the dancers that my calls contain reliable information about the timing of
the dance.
Second, in cases where I think inspiring dancers circle briskly *is*
worthwhile--for example, when "circle left 3/4
(6); pass through (2)" is
followed by "new neighbors balance"--I think it is no sin to finish the
call "pass through" before beat 6 of the circle. In fact, in such
cases, I usually give the call "pass through" on beats 3 and 4.
That seems to be what most callers do in this case. That's what I was
doing...until I resolved to fix the structure of my calls to match the
actual dance timing.
It is not a "sin" to call early. Nor is it a "sin" to attempt to
teach the
timing of the dance with verbal instructions. What I hope to avoid is
standing before a mixed crowd of dancers. Asking an excellent band to hold
their music. And asking a wonderful dance community to hold off on their
social interactions and listen patiently while I attempt to explain the
timing of the dance verbally with counted beats, steps, or whatever. Then,
when the music begins, to embarrass myself by giving my calls either early
or late. And that is why I asked for help here.
And I got some very good suggestions. Hopefully I can now call the dance
with more confidence and the dancers will feel more confidence because my
calls are consistent with the timing of the dance.
The dancers in your video look like a competent group of regulars who are
able to adapt to poorly-structured calls quickly and graciously. I'm sure
they have a lot of practice at it. I find it very productive to be more
diligent in my own calling.
Well-structured calling is not easy. It does however make a subtle but
significant difference in how confident the dancers feel--particularly at
open, public social events. That is why I structure my calls carefully and
write the calls out verbatim on my cards. That is also why I advocate for
callers at open public contra dances to use dance cards when calling.
Making up calls on the fly often puts the onus on the dancers to get the
timing right.
- Greg McKenzie
West Coast, USA