To add to the history that Bree offered, the last time Honor Among Thieves was
posted on this most excellent list (by John McIntire), Alan Winston took it
further back yet. So the whole story, as I can put it together from what
everyone has said, is as follows:
Alan said that the 'chase' figure was originally found in Playford’s 1701 ed,
Cheshire Rounds, a longways duple minor formation like contra. It then migrated
across the sea to become incorporated into Appalachian dancing. Ted Sanella
encountered the move in these old-time southern Appalachian square dances, and
in the mode of artists everywhere, nabbed it to incorporate into modern American
contra - the first to do so with this particular move. Then in 1986, Penn Fix
took Ted's dance and added a P-Sw for all, to appeal to modern contra tastes.
What an interesting dance biography! Thanks to all of you scholars.
Tina