On Jan 11, 2023, at 7:42 PM, Joe Harrington via Contra
Callers <contracallers(a)lists.sharedweight.net> wrote:
Wow! This has been an amazing thread. Many thanks! (And I look forward to further
replies!)
Agreed. I’ve really enjoyed it.
Anyone care to compare the computer programs? Are
there more than Colin's and Will's, and has anyone tried both of those? I know
both Colin and Will are here, so we can stick to facts about what they do and have.
I use a custom-made FileMaker Pro database (with slightly separate versions for contras
and for english country dance). I also print the dances out on 8 1/2 x 6 1/2 pages and
carry them in a mini 3-ring binder, sorted by name (and categorization is done in the
database and printed table of contents).
It has trade-offs vs cards. Here are some that come to mind:
* It’s harder to lose and I have a copy on my phone and tablet.
* I don’t have to worry as much about dropping my cards and getting them all out of order
(though that can still happen to the printed notebook).
* It’s easier to make changes, at least in some ways, including global changes (I hesitate
to use the L and R words and derail this conversation, but you get the idea).
* It is easy to search and sort dances.
* In theory I could have multiple tables of contents with different groupings. In practice
I don’t do that; I just have one table sorted by formation.
* Any annotations need to be copied back from the cards to the database.
* It’s harder to riffle through the dances while coming up with a dance program (in
advance or modifying one on the fly), though removing the potential dances from the 3-ring
binder certainly works.
* There's a practical limit to the # of pages I can carry in one binder.
* Mini three-ring binders are harder to find than they used to be (the one I most recently
bought has a different spacing of rings than my old ones, ick).
* FileMaker Pro has gotten expensive.
* The way I get dances onto my phone and tablet is a bit ugly (dance db in the cloud, but
requires a manual step on the phone or tablet to copy the database to FileMaker Go, a free
app from the FileMaker folks).
Regards,
Russell