At 11:56 PM 5/29/2010, Colin Hume wrote:
It's the hot-shots who turn up their noses at
anything less than
the perfect contra dance experience, and you can do without them - I
expect there are plenty of other places they can go.
I think it would be interesting to explore the underlying assumptions
in the phrase: "...the perfect contra dance experience,..."
Here in Santa Cruz we are often having dances where 30% of the crowd
has been to ten, or fewer contra dances and first-timers make up
about 16% of the crowd. These dances have full halls and lots of
excitement. The PA system is cranked up and there are lots of
university students attending.
Granted: The dancing is often contumacious and the floor is
crowded. But the bands and callers usually enjoy the experience--and
the pay. The local dance society leadership is generally pleased
with the success of the series. It is encouraging to have so many
young people getting involved.
Personally, I cannot conceive of a "perfect contra dance experience"
with first-timers making up less than 10% of the crowd. Meeting and
dancing with newcomers adds a vitality and excitement to the
dance. Contras are perfectly designed to "sweep in" newcomers and my
experience is that the regulars welcome an opportunity to partner
with newcomers when the caller engages the regulars in the process of
hosting the visiting and new dancers. When the regulars feel
empowered by the caller they will be enthusiastic about partnering
with new people. And that goes for the hot shots as well. Every
enthusiast loves to share what they are passionate about with someone
who is relaxed and willing to learn. This is one of the greatest
joys of contra dancing.
What is the perfect contra dance? If we, as callers, view the answer
as a dance made up of "major league" dancers only, then I believe we
are not only being unrealistic about the future of the dance form,
but we are also cheating ourselves and the dancers out of one of the
greatest pleasures of contra dancing.
Integrating the dance floor is vital because once the newcomers are
successfully paired up with regulars about 90% of the problems
discussed on this list simply go away, and 90% of what is being
"taught" in the beginner's orientation becomes unnecessary.
If our vision includes newcomers and casual visiting dancers at a
"town hall" style community social event then our role as callers is
very different than the role of a caller at an exclusive event
limited to contra dance enthusiasts. Integrating the dance floor
would have to be our first priority and how to do that is central to
the skills needed by the caller.
I would be interested in hearing from others about their ideas for
integrating the dance hall, particularly without using subterfuge,
and without implying that anyone is behaving poorly.
Greg McKenzie