Hi all,
And thanks Louise for articulating the issue so clearly and kindly.
However, I’m aware that Maia asked specifically that we avoid devolving
into a thread about gendered dance roles and once again we have. Can we
take this off thread? Kat K already started an alternate thread — I’ll go
give that bump.
From my perspective, insisting on dancing with someone even though they
have selected another partner and ignoring initial requests to stick to the
thread’s topic come from similar places (of valuing one’s own preferences
over community priorities). Let’s not do either!
Tanya H. Merchant
On Tue, Mar 12, 2024 at 08:54 Alan J Rosenthal via Contra Callers <
contracallers(a)lists.sharedweight.net> wrote:
I believe it's traditional that the roles have
been *called* "woman" and
"man", but I don't believe that it's traditional that they have always
been *actually* danced by people of the specified gender. For example,
I think that there's a long history of gender-segregated dance where
people are all [believed to be] one particular gender and they all dance
together, half of them taking each dance role. Sometimes for practice
before they dare to be seen dancing by the "opposite" sex at the fancy
ball;
sometimes because of sex-phobia under a presumption of heterosexuality.
And plenty of other reasons that people have not adhered to the gender
designations for the roles, for a long time.
regards,
ajr, dancing in and near Toronto, Canada
p.s. I like the young people's saying that "tradition is just peer
pressure from dead people". If doing something the way we've always
done it is fun for everyone and connects you to people at other times
and places, that's cool. But if your response to the question (this is
a quotation) "if I show up at [that dance] with my boyfriend, how will
people react?" is "well, you'll be required to dance exclusively with
women as partners all night because that's the way we've always done it",
then that's not cool, and your dance community will continue to shrink.
_______________________________________________
Contra Callers mailing list -- contracallers(a)lists.sharedweight.net
To unsubscribe send an email to contracallers-leave(a)lists.sharedweight.net