Thanks, Tom - good point re: the variability of "shadow" positions. Even
experienced callers sometimes identify the wrong shadow in a walk-through,
and when dancers get the wrong idea chaos ensues.
On a separate but related note: This raises for me an interesting question:
clarifying the terminology differences among "corner", "shadow", and
"trail
buddy".
It strikes me that the use of "corner" in squares focuses dancers on the
spatial position (lh lady, rh gent), and thus allows for the fact that
(depending on whether the square is progressive or keeper) the corner may
be the same person or may be a different person each iteration of the
dance. The use of "shadow" in longways dances implies that it's the same
person every time, regardless of their spatial relation to you within the
major set.
The difference between those two seems clear to me - which leaves "trail
buddy", a term i'm always fuzzy on. When is an interaction a "trail
buddy"
rather than a "shadow"? (Four-face-four dances seem an obvious example.)
Does the somewhat interchangeable use of the two terms in standard longways
dances create undue confusion for the dancers?
Feel free to direct me to archived SW threads if this is a discussion
that's already been had!
~ tavi
Message: 3
Date: Wed, 18 Jan 2012 16:23:45 -0500
From: Tom Hinds <twhinds(a)earthlink.net>
To: callers(a)sharedweight.net
Subject: [Callers] shadow
Message-ID: <ACAB9D2C-67F7-4055-BC0F-183E5F4FB664(a)earthlink.net>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII; delsp=yes; format=flowed
We shouldn't confuse new callers by failing to point out that there
are other contras that use a different shadow. The shadow Brian
speaks of is similar to the corner in a square. The other shadow
could be compared to a right-hand lady (left-hand gent) in a square.
Just by looking at the positioning and timing in the B2 it would make
sense for the shadow to be of the 'corner' variety.
If it was a r-h lady (left-hand gent) shadow the instructions would
probably say allemande left partner once around. In this dance using
a 'corner' shadow would ensure a longer partner swing.
When you're not sure, it's always a good idea to diagram the
choreography.
Great dance!
T