22 Oct
2016
22 Oct
'16
12:33 a.m.
Hi all
I haven't yet called Beneficial Tradition, but think it might be a good
fit for an upcoming dance. Does it get weird at the ends or does it
flow reasonably well? I danced it years ago and don't remember. If you
pull by RH to go out on the right diagonal, do you cross solo to the
other side to make space for the next person to come out on the right
diagonal?
Kalia
22 Oct
22 Oct
12:47 a.m.
New subject: Fw: Beneficial Tradition end effects
When you come to the end - do nothing for one pull by - do not cross set. It will mean
doing 2 rights or 2 lefts in a row (since you are out for one pull by)
If there are an even number of couples - no one is ever out more than that one pull by.
The end effects have never caused a problem any time I have called this.
Mac McKeever
----- Forwarded Message -----
From: Kalia Kliban via Callers <callers(a)lists.sharedweight.net>
To: Caller's discussion list <callers(a)sharedweight.net>
Sent: Friday, October 21, 2016 7:33 PM
Subject: [Callers] Beneficial Tradition end effects
Hi all
I haven't yet called Beneficial Tradition, but think it might be a good
fit for an upcoming dance. Does it get weird at the ends or does it
flow reasonably well? I danced it years ago and don't remember. If you
pull by RH to go out on the right diagonal, do you cross solo to the
other side to make space for the next person to come out on the right
diagonal?
Kalia
_______________________________________________
Callers mailing list
Callers(a)lists.sharedweight.net
http://lists.sharedweight.net/listinfo.cgi/callers-sharedweight.net
12:56 a.m.
On 2016-10-21 1733, Kalia Kliban via Callers wrote:
Hi all
I haven't yet called Beneficial Tradition, but think it might be a good
fit for an upcoming dance. Does it get weird at the ends or does it
flow reasonably well? I danced it years ago and don't remember. If you
pull by RH to go out on the right diagonal, do you cross solo to the
other side to make space for the next person to come out on the right
diagonal?
Kalia
Oh, _that_ dance. Cool. Now I know it's name.
We danced that at Chehalis this Sept. Was great fun. I don't recall any
overt weirdness, however I wasn't really looking at the ends throughout
the whole of the dance.
--
The penny dropped when I was reading the directions at hand, thinking,
"This looks fun", and then read in Mary Dart's book,
--
"A dance I wrote a few years ago called 'The Beneficial Tradition,' . .
. I think it started in Philadelphia that they discovered they had a
little extra time on their hands, so that after they pull by each of
those hands they go, "hey!" or "ho!" or something like that, and they
throw their free hand up in the air behind their heads. (Pearl 1990"
--
In Becky Hill's collection is, (possibly from Dan Pearl),
"Becket, double L/CW prog
This one needs strong, clear four-beat phrases in B2. More driving or
exhuberant, and not as mysterious or in a minor key."
--
From "Give-and-Take" (Larry Jennings)
"Neutrals must participate in the left-hand crossings,
partners playing the part of neighbors. One dancer at each end
stands pat during each diagonal crossing."
--
From the RPDLW #24 / 2011 syllabus:
"At the beginning of the dance, ladies should look on
the left diagonal for a new lady with whom to allemande. The rule for
diagonal action applies: at the ends of the set, if there is nobody to
pull by with on the diagonal, stay put! Also, in B1, note that the
ladies chain precedes the forward and back. This sets up B2 well, but is
opposite to what often happens, and so dancers may forget at times.
(In the original dance the A1 included a wave: Ladies allemande left
once around and give right hand to partner to form a wave (4), balance
the wave (4) and swing your partner (8). Lynn omits the balance.)"
Thanks for the ID of the dance Kalia. That's a keeper.
Cheers, John
--
J.D. Erskine
Victoria, BC
23 Oct
23 Oct
2 a.m.
The biggest trick to dancing/calling Beneficial Tradition is to do
precicely what we tell folks not to do for a R&L Thru -- pull by and HOLD
ON to let that turn you back to face back in. Then let go and pull by with
the other hand. Think about how new dancers always try to do a R&L thru
with hands, and then do that. Will put you in just the right spot. And as
others have said above, when you don't have someone to pull by with, just
stay put and pull by with the person that comes to you from the next pull
by that everyone else does.
Jack
On Fri, Oct 21, 2016 at 8:56 PM JD Erskine via Callers <
callers(a)lists.sharedweight.net> wrote:
On 2016-10-21 1733, Kalia Kliban via Callers wrote:
--
Jack Mitchell
Durham, NC
Hi all
I haven't yet called Beneficial Tradition, but think it might be a good
fit for an upcoming dance. Does it get weird at the ends or does it
flow reasonably well? I danced it years ago and don't remember. If you
pull by RH to go out on the right diagonal, do you cross solo to the
other side to make space for the next person to come out on the right
diagonal?
Kalia
Oh, _that_ dance. Cool. Now I know it's name.
We danced that at Chehalis this Sept. Was great fun. I don't recall any
overt weirdness, however I wasn't really looking at the ends throughout
the whole of the dance.
--
The penny dropped when I was reading the directions at hand, thinking,
"This looks fun", and then read in Mary Dart's book,
--
"A dance I wrote a few years ago called 'The Beneficial Tradition,' . .
. I think it started in Philadelphia that they discovered they had a
little extra time on their hands, so that after they pull by each of
those hands they go, "hey!" or "ho!" or something like that, and
they
throw their free hand up in the air behind their heads. (Pearl 1990"
--
In Becky Hill's collection is, (possibly from Dan Pearl),
"Becket, double L/CW prog
This one needs strong, clear four-beat phrases in B2. More driving or
exhuberant, and not as mysterious or in a minor key."
--
From "Give-and-Take" (Larry Jennings)
"Neutrals must participate in the left-hand crossings,
partners playing the part of neighbors. One dancer at each end
stands pat during each diagonal crossing."
--
From the RPDLW #24 / 2011 syllabus:
"At the beginning of the dance, ladies should look on
the left diagonal for a new lady with whom to allemande. The rule for
diagonal action applies: at the ends of the set, if there is nobody to
pull by with on the diagonal, stay put! Also, in B1, note that the
ladies chain precedes the forward and back. This sets up B2 well, but is
opposite to what often happens, and so dancers may forget at times.
(In the original dance the A1 included a wave: Ladies allemande left
once around and give right hand to partner to form a wave (4), balance
the wave (4) and swing your partner (8). Lynn omits the balance.)"
Thanks for the ID of the dance Kalia. That's a keeper.
Cheers, John
--
J.D. Erskine
Victoria, BC
_______________________________________________
Callers mailing list
Callers(a)lists.sharedweight.net
http://lists.sharedweight.net/listinfo.cgi/callers-sharedweight.net
2741
days inactive
2742
days old
contracallers@lists.sharedweight.net
3 comments
4 participants
participants (4)
-
Jack Mitchell via Callers -
JD Erskine via Callers
-
Kalia Kliban via Callers
-
Mac Mckeever via Callers